High Quality ‘Greener’ Coatings through Automated Viscosity Monitoring and Control
The challenge in the coatings industry for existing and emerging markets is to lower cost of applying coating, optimize coating material use, recycle materials, and to deliver extremely predictable and robust coatings. Viscosity is an important property of coating and is crucial both to ensure quality of coating material as well as the application process. Monitoring and controlling viscosity of the coating through the complete ecosystem achieves the two highly desired property of a coat – consistency and thickness. Factory automation/ Industry 4.0 solutions utilize inline viscometers to contribute to a more resource-efficient, economical and greener coating process in addition to delivering top quality coating performance.
Industrial coatings perform a great variety of functions, from corrosion and abrasion resistance and UV protection, through thermal and electrical insulation, to appearance enhancement. The market for coatings spans multiple sectors including industrial, automotive, marine, coil, packaging, transportation and building materials. New and emerging markets need cutting-edge, engineered coating solutions with tightly controlled performance characteristics. The challenge in the coatings industry for existing and emerging markets is to lower costs while optimizing performance and reducing waste and environmental impact.
Figure.1. Examples of coating applications
With huge application areas and growing demand from the end-use sectors, this industry is looking for new ways to improve efficiency, lead time, and capacity utilization. Industry leaders across sectors are moving towards adoption of more advanced technologies such as automation, industrial internet of things (IIoT) and simulation techniques.
Application of Coating
Coating and finishing processes use advanced technologies to produce durable surfaces, high quality finishes, while maximizing process efficiency and meeting environmental regulations. Surface finish consistency, product quality and variety play a vital role in ensuring customer satisfaction. Coating quantity and quality have a large and direct impact on manufacturing, sales and maintenance costs.
Viscosity of the coating material is central to achieving consistency. It is an effective indicator of concentration of coating solids in the fluid, which is the basis for the thickness and uniformity of the film. Performance parameters all depend on the viscosity of the liquid coating at the point of application. These include coating film build, transfer efficiency, coating thickness and deposition, color match, finished surface qualities and chemical resistance. Viscosity is the main factor influencing the thickness and adhesion of the coating. Proper viscosity control assures the quality and lifetime of the coat, helping meet the highest demands on the quality and productivity of the coating process.
A typical coating system includes: supplies of base stock and make-up fluid, an agitated mix tank, a pump, the feed line to the applicator, the applicator itself, and the return line to the mix tank. The applicator can utilize a dip, roll, spray, sputter, flow or other process. If the coating solution is not sufficiently viscous, the coating on the product may not be sufficiently thick to provide protection. However, if viscosity is too low, film sagging will result on vertical surfaces leading to unevenness in coating. This requires finishes with complex rheological properties. They must have low viscosity during spraying, and much higher viscosity when the material lands on the surface to be coated. In addition, coating viscosity depends on temperature, so that maintaining finish quality requires compensating the viscosity of coating material for the ambient application temperature.
Current state of coating viscosity monitoring and control
Viscosity is typically measured in the laboratory using a rotational instrument, such as a Brookfield-type viscometer or a high-precision rheometer. This enables strict temperature control, which is essential to characterizing the rheological properties of coating materials. However, these measurements, performed on samples pulled from the production floor, may take hours or even days to analyze, so that their measurements may not characterize the actual state of the materials currently being applied.
On the production floor, viscosity is typically measured by timing its flow from a funnel-like device, such as a Ford or similar efflux cup. The operator fills the cup with the formulation, and measures the time necessary for the cup to empty. The longer the time, the higher the viscosity. This is usually done at intervals of 15 minutes or more, so that deviations in viscosity can only be detected after a considerable amount of coat has already been applied. Also, temperature control of cup measurements is difficult if not impossible, leading to possibly large discrepancies between measured values and actual viscosity at the point of application. Such offline measurements cannot capture viscosity changes due to temperature changes, blending variations and evaporation as they occur.
Variation in material temperature leads to viscosity changes in the coating materials, resulting in structural differences or sagging. In most paint systems there is a tendency of sedimentation of the contained binder and pigment components. Inhomogeneous coating material inevitably leads to an inadequate coating result. Settled components may lead to blockages and to the gradual blocking of lines. Flaked coat components result in soiling of the coat film. The variations, difficult to control result in incorrect film thickness and consequentially lead to off-quality unusable end products, with unacceptable visual or other performance characteristics.
Table.1. Some of the typical coating defects, and their causes
|Orange peel||Surface looks uneven like the skin of an orange||Nozzle held too far away from the surface; shop temperature is too high to alter the viscosity; spray nozzle is clogged.||Inline viscosity measurement will flag up clogging and temperature compensated viscosity will avoid the issue|
|Mottled surface||Uneven appearance (generally affects metallic coatings)||Paint not mixed thoroughly before application||Inline viscosity measurement will show the high variation in measurement|
|Runs or sags||Coating does not adhere uniformly to the surface being painted||Paint drying too slowly, finishing coats applied too thick||Viscosity would have shown up higher than setpoint, automatic mode will have corrected viscosity|
|Color variations||Lacking color consistency across painted/coated units||Inconsistent and irregular properties of coat due to lack in effective and continuous control over the viscosity||Viscosity monitoring will show as large variation in viscosity, automatic control will avoid the issue altogether|
|Solvent pop||Retention of excessive solvent/occluded air in the wet film, which escapes by erupting through the surface||Inaccurate control over coating formulation viscosity and temperature prior to application||Automatic control of viscosity avoids use of excess solvent, reducing the chances of entrapment|
|Air entrapment||Similar to solvent popping or bubbles||Inadequate monitoring of paint line conditions||Inline viscometer will alert operators to the condition|
|Blisters||Bubbles near the surface of a film during oven cure that do not break through the surface.||Viscosity of the surface of the film increases to a high level, trapping the volatile solvent at a lower level||Optimizing solvent use and ensuring correct viscosity of coating through inline viscometer avoids this issue|
Inline viscosity measurement to the rescue
Fortunately, solutions are available that enable real-time, inline viscosity measurement and control, making it possible to detect process variations as they happen. Viscosity fluctuations due to solvent or coating addition, temperature changes, and evaporation can be automatically compensated before they affect coating quality. Continuous viscosity monitoring can be correlated with coating material and solvent consumption, as well as film thickness and quality, in order to strategically alter process parameters for optimizing the coating process. Inline viscosity control can result in higher product quality, increased yields, significant savings in the use of coatings and coatings solvents, and minimize the downtime of the coating process, compared to traditional, off-line measurements with the efflux cup.
Solvent evaporation, addition of fresh coating or solvent to the mixing tank, and sedimentation may lead to viscosity change in the coating materials, resulting in coating defects or excessive coating and solvent consumption.
Temperature is also a crucial variable in determining viscosity. Unfortunately, temperatures in production environments are often not well controlled. Viscosity, which reflects solids content in the coating, must be correct despite temperature variations. Cup measurements have neither temperature measurement nor control, so cannot be directly compared with actual spraying temperature. This can lead to variations in coating quality as the process temperature varies.
Drivers for coaters’ adoption of real-time viscosity management
There are four significant factors that make viscosity management important in coating applications:
- End-product quality: Poor coating quality can adversely affect the desirable properties of the coats – finished surface qualities, coating deposition, protection properties and chemical reactivity. All these properties depend on the how well the coating process is controlled, hence controlling viscosity is critical.
- Reducing costs by reducing waste: Over-mixing can not only affect the quality of end product but waste ingredients, raw materials, time and energy. Viscosity management in the mixing process can identify the endpoint reliably and accurately, thus leading to significant reduction in raw materials consumption, energy usage, rejects and waste.
- Efficiency: Hassle free, real time monitoring of viscosity eliminates costly and time-consuming laboratory analysis, which often results in delayed response to changes in the coat Ensuring consistency throughout the coating process significantly reduces reject rates, saving cost and time while improving profit margins.
- Automation: Automatically monitoring and controlling coating preparation and application process takes out a manual sampling and testing step that is prone to errors and relieves operators to focus on the quality of the final product.
Coating applications need advanced process technology for accurate, real-time in-line viscosity measurement and control
Inline viscosity measurement calls for a compact, robust viscosity sensor, combined with a measurement and control system that translates the sensor’s reading into information used to monitor and control the process viscosity.
A technology that has proven especially applicable to inline measurements makes use of a mechanical resonator whose oscillations are damped by the viscosity of the coating material. An electronics system connected to the resonant sensor measures its damping, and converts this to a viscosity value. In addition, a temperature sensing device installed in the viscosity sensor provides a measurement of coating material temperature exactly at the point of viscosity measurement.
Resonant sensor technology provides a solution that is uniquely adapted to inline coatings monitoring and control. They fulfill many of the requirements for reliable and accurate measurement:
- Robustness – they maintain accuracy and repeatability over wide variations in process parameters. They are free of the rotating parts and narrow gaps that are typical of laboratory viscometers and rheometers. Further they can operate in environments with high levels of vibration and shock.
- Operator independence – both efflux cups and laboratory instruments require skillful operators to maintain reliable, repeatable measurements. Without adequate training and attention to detail, operator-dependent methods are generally unreliable for maintaining tight control over the coating process.
- Compatibility with automated monitoring and control systems – Implementation of Industry 4.0 methodologies requires seamless interfacing of measurement systems with existing plant technology. Resonant viscometer systems provide a wide spectrum of output options, from 4-20 mA current loops through ethernet, RS485 and CAN bus interfaces running industry standard protocols like Modbus, EthernetIP, CANOpen, Profinet, JSON, OPC UA for direct acquisition of data by machine PLC and factory SCADA systems. Offline methods, by contrast, require the intermediate stage of the operator entering viscosity values manually, a process that is prone to lapses and errors and does not create complete traceability of the process.
- Tight temperature control – a good resonant sensor has temperature measurement integrated into the sensing element. This enables characterization of the coating material at the point of viscosity measurement, rather than under laboratory conditions.
- Simple maintenance – the most advanced resonant sensors expose hermetically sealed, mechanically robust sensor elements to the coating material. They are free of gaps and cavities, and can be easily cleaned in place (CIP) or removed an simply wiped clean with a solvent-soaked rag. Systems are even available that enable washing the sensor in the line, coupled with self-check systems that indicate whether the sensor is clean and free of any contamination.
- Cost effective – despite relatively higher initial cost when compared with efflux cups, inline resonant measurement systems are generally far less expensive that typical laboratory instruments, especially when the recurring cost of skilled laboratory technicians is factored into the equation. The lifetime cost of these inline viscometers are significantly lower than manual cups when labor cost is taken into consideration.
An example of a resonant sensor that offers these advantages is the Rheonics SRV inline viscometer (see Fig. 2 below)
Its compact form factor allows direct installation in the coating line, close to the point of application. Its intrinsically high shear rate, well up onto the high shear plateau of typical paint systems, produces measurements that accurately predict the behavior of the coating under the flow conditions typical of spray application.
Figure.2. Inline viscometer SRV (source: rheonics)
Viscosity and temperature: an intimate relationship
The viscosity of nearly all liquids is highly temperature dependent. A viscosity measurement without tight and accurate temperature control is meaningless. For this reason, it is essential that the temperature of the fluid is measured as close to the point of viscosity measurement as is practical. Instruments such as the Rheonics SRV have accurate temperature measurement integrated into the sensing element so that the value of every viscosity measurement is accompanied by a temperature value.
Measuring the fluid temperature at exactly the point of viscosity measurement has a further advantage. It is possible to characterize the relationship of coating viscosity to temperature by varying its temperature over the range expected in the coating line, while measuring its viscosity with the inline viscometer. The resulting measurements can be used to derive a formula that allows the fluid’s viscosity at any temperature in this range to be calculated from a measurement at any other temperature in this range. Therefore, the so-called temperature compensated viscosity becomes independent of the actual process temperature. Temperature compensated viscosity is important because it reflects some very relevant process parameters, such as pigment loading or solvent concentration, both of which are, in themselves, independent of temperature.
Reliable viscosity measurement enables predictive control for Industry 4.0 integration
Some of the key elements in bringing coating lines up to Industry 4.0 standards include:
- Consistency in coating through automated corrective actions
- Agility in dealing with new product variants in production, compliance and product provenance
- Big data provides robust evidence to base decisions for greater efficiency
- Interconnection and information transparency allow for operators to make decisions both inside and outside of production facilities, thus enabling decentralization of decisions
- Reduction in carbon emissions – Optimizing the coating process reduces material usage, energy consumption and waste – all of these reduce the CO2 budget of the coating process significantly
- Return on investment (ROI) on typical inline viscometers are on the order of 3-6 months.
Figure.3. Schematic showing the inline integration of viscometer and controller in automotive painting/coating process.
Toward higher accuracy, reliable and agile coating process control
Resonant viscosity sensors are often paired with conventional PLC-based control systems. These typically do not make use of all the advantages required by modern, Industry 4.0 compatible sensor systems.
More sophisticated systems can, for example, make use of the highly accurate and reproducible measurements provided by resonant sensors to enable “lock and load” setting of coating parameters by checking actual measurements against a database of coating materials and established job parameters. One such system is the Rheonics CoatControl with ViscoLock software that enables online control of temperature-compensated viscosity of coats in multiple lines simultaneously. Multiple sensors can be managed from a single dashboard spread across the factory floor. Coating consistency across multiple lines in the factory can be achieved even under varying temperatures and evaporation conditions through automation of the dosing system with a controller using continuous real-time viscosity measurements. Coaters can finally achieve complete track and trace of every coating operation.
Modern sensor and control systems advances coating process control to conform to Industry 4.0 requirements. By pairing accurate, reliable inline sensors with sophisticated online control systems, viscosity control can be brought up to the standards required of high-speed, automated coating lines, while enhancing productivity and conformity to environmental standards. Such systems are open to future developments in the field, enabling agile adaptation to changing coatings formulations and improvements in application technology.
- Emphasize Increased Efficiency, Productivity, Agility, and Flexibility While Maintaining Quality and Safety, Advances in Paint and Coating Manufacturing Equipment: https://www.paint.org/coatingstech-magazine/articles/advances-in-paint-and-coating-manufacturing-equipment/
- Optimum Viscosity for Paint Application: https://www.paint.org/coatingstech-magazine/articles/optimum-viscosity-paint-application/
- SRV operating principle: https://rheonics.com/whitepapers/
- An Update on Sustainability in the Coatings Industry – https://www.paint.org/coatingstech-magazine/articles/an-update-on-sustainability-in-the-coatings-industry/
Rheonics Solutions for the Coating industry
To explore more about our solutions for coatings industry, please visit the solutions page.
Defects in glaze coating are driven by variation in glazing causing color differences, coating thickness variation, cracks. Monitoring and controlling viscosity lead to dramatic drop in defects. Key benefits of…
Real-time inline viscosity measurement in cardboard production is essential for continuous quality control, avoid waste and optimize energy consumption. Starch glue exhibits complex rheological behavior and its viscosity is not…
Optimum process performance can be ensured by monitoring slurry health continuously. It helps to accommodate tighter purity and blend accuracy requirements of next generation slurries. Newer slurries not well defined…
Emulsions are used in almost every aspect of daily lives. Their processing and development expands across many industries – chemicals, coating, food, cosmetics, adhesives, industrial fluids, pharmaceutical products, oil &…
Adhesives and sealants are used widely for joining , protecting and sealing systems in construction, manufacturing and maintenance. This industry is facing challenges due to the limited raw materials (reserve…
The global electrical insulation coatings market size in 2015 was USD 2 billion and is expected to grow significantly in the coming years, mainly due to developments in the power…
An enteric (delayed-release) coating is a barrier applied to oral medication that controls the location in the digestive tract where it is absorbed. The term “enteric” refers to the small…